MORE MAZE
6 people, all really cool, guy brought some nice sweet breads. Things looked up, but by the end of the session everyone was kinda down, worrying. I did not drink as much (maybe that's the issue?)
I talked to Patrick Stuart about this before I started, I asked if 1st Level LOTFP characters would survive the Maze. On reflection, I think that the actual level of the characters is semi-unimportant, b.c. the decisions the players made in the Maze (this time) were kinda independent of character level, but we'll see...
They go in the maze; immediately, one PC makes a ?wise? move to cut the return painting out of the frame and roll it up and take with her. This is crazy but it's OSR so I let it go; wild thinking the whole's biz. The Bondeye Repartee show up and freak out the PCs for a minute.
There's no real encounter 'til the Starlight room where they meet like 13 "Oku" trying to rob them. Things break down into combat and people start falling into each other's shadows as per the room (new readers: shadows create 10' pits in this room). After some lethal-ish combat the PCs willingly give up (most) of their gold and rations and everyone sets about rescuing each other from the pit.
From that point on, half the group grabs swords from the Throne room while the other half starts dealing with the Chess King two rooms over. The Chess King wants to be polished in exchange for safety "within his kingdom."* Meanwhile the "Oku" from earlier are crossing the rope bridge in between the Throne and the Chess room so two of the PCs, the ones with the swords, try cutting the bridge. Both get spiked by Oku arrows. One survives, and makes it back to the Chess King, where everyone camps out with his protection.
Two days of rest pass; another PC shows up out of the painting (they are carrying it with them). There's some encounters with Chameleon Woman and the Lion in Lapis Lazuli, neither of which can attack the PCs in the Chess King's "kingdom" due to the King's psychic powers. The PCs have fun yelling at the Lion and hurting its feelings.
They set out again. There's an encounter with the hypnodiscs and the nazca lines before some Orchidmen show up and everyone loses their nerve and jumps back through the painting. The painting is left lying on the ground next to the Ambush Scarab, to be dealt with by (someone, probably). Net loss for the PCs who lost everything they got (the swords, which fell into the pit beneath the rope bridge) and also got robbed and killed.
Everyone was emotionally down at the end b.c they got no treasure. Things seemed too hard. Then again, the risks they took-- fighting 13 "Oku", and trying to cut the rope bridge-- were pretty commiserate with the damage they took. Getting pwned and then trading sexual favors for safety with the Chess King... middling to bad.
RULES NOTES: I relaxed the "you don't get hp back inside of the dungeon" LOTFP bit. Seems hard not to do this, as I've done this before, with Legends of the Scarecrow. Maybe there's something I'm missing-- pleasures of hardcore gaming? Force PCs to leave, escape? Would like some clarification on this.
CONCLUSIONS: Describing each room was a challenge. MOTBM says not to read the description text but the players urged me to do that, with good results. I may start reading description text more, or at least referring to it more. I usually say something like "giant weird line painting" while the text says it more eloquently.
OTHER CONCLUSION: I'm too obsessed with this book for my own good. I feel like I'm bringing people into my obsession with too little practical thought for their own enjoyment. Everything is too hard, with too little reward. I fear that hardlining OSR-style play is driving people away from the game.
THIRD CONCLUSION: 1st level play, inside the MOTBM, isn't impossible, and there's many encounters which are deathtraps no matter if you're 1st or 5th. But the difference is that with 1st level you have 4hp so you're able to advance less far without taking a break. 4hp is a really frustrating amount to start with, but, again, maybe there's that OSR hardline carrot somewhere.
FOURTH, POSSIBLE CONCLUSION: Give everybody more hp?????? Any thoughts would appreciated if anyone's reading this.
*One of the PCs made this super sexual which is awesome.